The Wrath of Nightmare Rarity: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #7 Review

Will the ponies be able to fight a friend?

Will the ponies be able to fight a friend?

Comic Written by Heather Nuhfer, Drawn by Amy Mebberson, Colored by Heather Breckel, Lettered by Neil Uyetake, and Edited by Bobby Curnow

Review by Andrew Mathieu

After being kidnapped and having her greatest fears consume her, Rarity has become the new Nightmare Moon.  After having overcome the obstacles put before them in the last issue, Twilight, Princess Luna, Spike, and their pony friends must now try to save their lost friend from the clutches of darkness.  However, with a legion of corrupted denizens at her disposal, Nightmare Rarity may not be so easy to overcome.

This issue, at its core, focused a small number of characters, and despite most of the ponies being in play, along with some nice cameos, they are mostly left by the wayside.  The first half of the issue helps us get aquinted with the new Nightmare Moon as her friends must fight of both her and the various shadow creatures at her beck and call.  Later the issue focus on Spike, as he tries his best to free Rarity, the pony he loves.

The dialogue from the ponies is spot on and true to each character, from Pinkie Pie’s attempt to free Rarity by telling an embarrassing story about her, to Fluttershy finding the beauty in one of the more grotesque creatures of the moon.  The scenes in Ponyville where Princess Celestia attempts to prepare the town’s citizens for an impending attack help illustrate the threat of Nightmare Moon nicely.  My main problem with this issue is the fact that Rarity as Nightmare Moon feels less groundbreaking to the ponies than I would have thought.  The pacing of the story doesn’t allow for much reflection on the pony’s part, nor does it allow them to question how their friend could have possibly fallen to the evil specter from their past.  The scenes featuring Spike are nice, showing just how much she cares for Rarity, as well as how resourceful the little dragon can be.  It does run a little long, though, and doesn’t leave anymore room for Twilight and her friends before the issue comes to an end.

The artwork from Amy Mebberson, with the colors of the Heather Breckel, continue the colorful symphony of fun I continue to adore from this series.  The characters look very animated and expressive, while the backgrounds are more mute and less important to the characters filling them.  Nightmare Rarity is also very well designed, with the stylish hair and uptight demeanor making a nice contrast to her predecessor.   The moon is a dark and dank place with its citizens matching the environments well, but the addition of the ponies (and dragon) help them dominate each panel.  It’s a nice mixture that really drives home the ponies are not from this world, which is an impressive feat.  Andy Price may be unbelievable meticulous in the minute details, but Mebberson and Breckel bring their own synergy to make the comic familiar to fans of the show, yet unique in their own colorful style.

My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #8 is a nice continuation of a decent story.  The setup has a ton of potential, but the end result is a lot less ambitious.  Not a bad way for the story to go by any means, but nothing that really blows me away.  The story is well told, the artwork continues to impressive, and the ending helps build anticipation for the grand finale.  A good, just short of great, pony adventure.

Writing:  3.5 out of 5

Artwork:  4 out of 5

Overall:  3.5 out of 5

The Search for Rarity: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #6 Review

The Ponies, Princess Luna, and Spike on a quest to find a friend.

The Ponies, Princess Luna, and Spike on a quest to find a friend.

Review by Andrew Mathieu

Comic Written by Heather Nuhfer, Drawn by Amy Mebberson, Colored by Heather Breckel, Lettered by Neil Uyetake, and Edited by Bobby Curnow

Last issue saw the abduction of Rarity to the moon, as well as the surprise arrival of Princess Celesia and Princess Luna.  With the help of a magic-infused lasso, Twilight, Spike, Pinkie, Dash, AJ, Fluttershy, and Princess Luna embark on a lunar adventure to rescue their friend.  However, dark forces are at work and they’ll stop on nothing to hold the ponies progress to achieve their terrifying goal.

This issue features some nice characterization.  The addition of Spike and Princess Luna, both of whom were largely absent from the previous story arc adds a some nice moments in the story.  There’s an early moment between Spike and Twilight that perfectly captures their big sister/little brother vibe that’s a constant throughout the series.  Luna, on the other hand, is an interesting character in general.  Given her dark past and lack of social skills, she’s a polar opposite of her older sister, despite the fact they share the same kingdom.  In this issue she’s seems surprisingly vulnerable despite her familiarity of her surroundings.  It’s nice to see the ponies help Luna overcome her lack of confidence, and likewise see Luna guide the ponies as best she can on this dangerous adventure.

The artwork is the same colorful and lively look that has become a staple of this series for me.  Even on the dark and dreary moon the ponies are able to make any environment lively with the varied color palettes.  While Amy Mebberson’s artwork isn’t as meticulous as Andy Price before her, she makes up for it with a lot of character detail and a look that is, while similar in design of the animated series, has a nice tone and feel all its own.  The colors from the amazing Heather Breckal help lend this world an amazing level of visual depth and clarity.

While the characterization is fantastic, the actual story in this issue is somewhat bland.  Without spoiling too much, this issue goes into further detail of a sequence from last issue.  While not outright bad, it does feel somewhat unnecessary and it feels like some moments were over before they started.  Nevertheless it’s an interesting look at these characters and doesn’t ruin the issue as a whole, nor does it impact the shocking cliffhanger.

My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #6 continues the series streak of great characters, blissfully colorful visuals, and self-contained entertainment.  The story may not be as interesting as the characters in it, but the strength of the writing and artwork carry it to a finish.

Writing:  3.5 out of 5

Artwork: 5 out of 5

Overall: 4 out of 5

Blackest Night Mare: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #5 Review

A new creative team and a new adventure for everyone's favorite ponies!

A new creative team and a new adventure for everyone’s favorite ponies!

Reviewed by Andrew Mathieu

Comic Written by Heather Nuhfer, Drawn by Amy Mebberson, Colored by Heather Breckel, Lettered by Neil Uyetake, and Edited by Bobby Curnow

After a wonderful first arc featuring great character work, amazing art, and the delightfully sinister villain in Queen Chrysalis, this ongoing series receives a changing of the guard with a brand new writer Heather Nuhfer, and artwork by series cover artist Amy Mebberson.  The story begins with Twilight Sparkle being plagued with nightmares. After finding out her best friends, save for Spike, have also been plagued with similar nightmares, they all decide to have a sleepover at Pinkie Pie’s.  However, evil forces are at work, one of the ponies is in major danger, and a visit from Equestria royalty ushers in a new adventure.

The issue as a whole is well written.  Heather Nuhfer has a nice handle on all the ponies, especially Rainbow Dash.  Dash gets a large amount of dialogue, making me believe the multicolored pony has a fan in Nuhfer.  She’s mostly true to Dash’s character, but I don’t think Rainbow should be this talkative and random to the level of Pinkie Pie, something Pinkie amusingly comments on.

(Spoiler Alert: Skip following paragraph if you’d like to experience the story for yourself)

Another character Nuhfer writes well is the criminally underused Princess Luna.  In the animated series, she has not gotten that much screen time, so it’s nice to have this comic arc utilize her to such a degree.  Nuhfer’s Luna is somewhat subdued and somewhat reclusive, yet intelligent and authoritative.  Her design definitely represents her nature with her dark color palette that is in stark contrast to the other ponies.  I look forward to having her play a role in this story arc, and I think Nuhfer does a good job of fleshing her out.

On the artistic side, things are looking good.  While Amy Mebberson’s art isn’t as detailed and intricate as Andy Price before her, it’s full of personality and a nice storybook quality.  With less on the page, she’s able to give the characters some details in expression and movement.  There is this one scene in the issue that looks into each pony’s personal nightmare, and some are absolutely heart wrenching, despite most only taking up a single panel on the page.  Her style is very attractive, and the colors from Heather Breckel continue to make this one of the most pleasant-looking comics I read.

All in all, this story is off to a good start.  Only time will tell if this arc can live up to the extremely high standards of the previous one, but I have high hopes.  This wasn’t the best issue I’ve read, but it was still really good.

Story:  3.5 out of 5

Artwork 4 out of 5

Overall: 4 out of 5

Queen Chrysalis vs. Twilight Sparkle: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #4 Review

The one on one Pony Battle a year in the making!

The pony brawl to end them all!

Writer: Katie Cook  Artist: Andy Price  Colorist Heather Breckel  Letterer Neil Uyetake  Editor: Bobby Curnow

Katie Cook and Andy Price\ have completely delighted me with this ongoing comic book series.  They’ve done more than just channel the fun and good will of the animated series through this serial; they’ve taken established stories and characters and have spun a very enjoyable story to a new format.  For fans of the animated series or comic book readers looking for an all ages title that goes above and beyond the call, My Little Pony: Friendship of Magic is well worth a look.

As the fourth and final part of “The Return of Queen Chrysalis,” Twilight and her band of merry ponies march into the castle of the Queen to save the Cutie Mark Crusaders from the clutches of the changeling kingdom.  Meanwhile, the magic enhancing Secretariat Comet is fast approaching, Queen Chrysalis springs her final trap, and a battle building since part two of “A Canterlot Wedding” finally comes to fruition.

Katie Cook has proven since issue one that she just gets these characters.  Everypony sounds true to their animated counterparts, and Cook has done especially well with Queen Chrysalis and the Cutie Mark Crusaders.  The Queen just exudes a charisma and personality that’s just too good to resist.  The way she toys with Twilight and company is just funny to watch and read, making her one of the best elements of this whole arc.  Meanwhile Apple Bloom, Sweetie Bell and Scootaloo are all handled remarkably well.  Their constant banter has been pretty funny, and the fact that they can drive even Queen Chrysalis to near insanity is a testament to their enduring nature.

Once again, Andy Price and colorist Heather Breckel completely knock it out of the park in what is undoubtably the best looking issue so far.  This issue is much darker than previous issues, but the colors are still vibrant.  While the animated look is still intact, it’s the more striking and serious moments that stand out with excellent lighting, an insane amount of detail, and nice little visual touches that help make each panel feel like scenes rather than snapshots.  One particular scene features a flash of lightning, causing Rainbow Dash, Applejack, and Rarity to protect Scootaloo, Apple Bloom and Sweetie Belle, respectively.  The scene is memorable to me because each pony protects their filly in a different way: Dash flies Scootaloo to safety, AJ covers Apple Bloom using her whole body, and Rarity engulfs Sweetie Bell in her arms.  Visual scenes like this are sprinkled throughout the whole issue, and it just gives the comic so much weight and charm.  It’s easy to find something new if you read it again.

The highlight of the book is the visually spectacular battle between Twilight and Chrysalis, which just blew me away.  It’s probably the most intense battle in Friendship is Magic, and that’s counting the cartoon.  If there is one flaw with this issue, it’s that the battle feels is a little uneven.  Without giving anything away, it’s a great one on one fight, but one that feels a little too short.

This issue closes out an amazing first arc to a great new comic book series.  It also marks the (hopefully temporary) departure of writer and artist as a new duo will helm the next story arc.  Even so, this was a great way to open a comic book based on such a beloved property.  It introduces everyone’s favorite ponies to a whole new audience and entertainment format.  This comic has been a lot of fun, and I can’t wait to read more!

Writing 4.5/5

Artwork 5/5

Overall 5/0

By Andrew Mathieu