Blackest Night Mare: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #5 Review

A new creative team and a new adventure for everyone's favorite ponies!

A new creative team and a new adventure for everyone’s favorite ponies!

Reviewed by Andrew Mathieu

Comic Written by Heather Nuhfer, Drawn by Amy Mebberson, Colored by Heather Breckel, Lettered by Neil Uyetake, and Edited by Bobby Curnow

After a wonderful first arc featuring great character work, amazing art, and the delightfully sinister villain in Queen Chrysalis, this ongoing series receives a changing of the guard with a brand new writer Heather Nuhfer, and artwork by series cover artist Amy Mebberson.  The story begins with Twilight Sparkle being plagued with nightmares. After finding out her best friends, save for Spike, have also been plagued with similar nightmares, they all decide to have a sleepover at Pinkie Pie’s.  However, evil forces are at work, one of the ponies is in major danger, and a visit from Equestria royalty ushers in a new adventure.

The issue as a whole is well written.  Heather Nuhfer has a nice handle on all the ponies, especially Rainbow Dash.  Dash gets a large amount of dialogue, making me believe the multicolored pony has a fan in Nuhfer.  She’s mostly true to Dash’s character, but I don’t think Rainbow should be this talkative and random to the level of Pinkie Pie, something Pinkie amusingly comments on.

(Spoiler Alert: Skip following paragraph if you’d like to experience the story for yourself)

Another character Nuhfer writes well is the criminally underused Princess Luna.  In the animated series, she has not gotten that much screen time, so it’s nice to have this comic arc utilize her to such a degree.  Nuhfer’s Luna is somewhat subdued and somewhat reclusive, yet intelligent and authoritative.  Her design definitely represents her nature with her dark color palette that is in stark contrast to the other ponies.  I look forward to having her play a role in this story arc, and I think Nuhfer does a good job of fleshing her out.

On the artistic side, things are looking good.  While Amy Mebberson’s art isn’t as detailed and intricate as Andy Price before her, it’s full of personality and a nice storybook quality.  With less on the page, she’s able to give the characters some details in expression and movement.  There is this one scene in the issue that looks into each pony’s personal nightmare, and some are absolutely heart wrenching, despite most only taking up a single panel on the page.  Her style is very attractive, and the colors from Heather Breckel continue to make this one of the most pleasant-looking comics I read.

All in all, this story is off to a good start.  Only time will tell if this arc can live up to the extremely high standards of the previous one, but I have high hopes.  This wasn’t the best issue I’ve read, but it was still really good.

Story:  3.5 out of 5

Artwork 4 out of 5

Overall: 4 out of 5

Advertisements

Ponies Divided and a Queen Delighted: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #3 Review

The Mane Six are split up as they continue their rescue mission.

The Mane Six are split up as they continue their rescue mission.

Comic Written by Katie Cook,  Art by Andy Price, Heather Breckel, Letter by Neil Uyetake, and Edited by Bobby Curnow

It’s hard to describe how much I love this series without sounding like a broken record.  The writing is great, the art is spectacular, and it matches the charm and fun of the animated series it’s based on while still feeling new and original.  After only three issues, it’s become my favorite comic book series in a long while, and I can’t tell you how delighted I feel with every new issue that arrives in the mail.

In this issue, Queen Chrysalis reminisces about her defeat from “A Canterlot Wedding” and her plot to get revenge on the pony who brought about her downfall, Twilight Sparkle.  Chrysalis, along with her loyal minions and Cutie Mark Crusader prisoners, continues to spy on Twilight and company, who have since split into three separate groups to get to the Changeling Kingdom.

Katie Cook has her deck full on the character side in this issue, having to juggle the pairing of Twilight and Fluttershy, Applejack and Rarity, Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie, as well as Spike, Queen Chrysalis, The Cutie Mark Crusaders, and a few others.  Luckily, not only is she able to give each pony their due time on the page, she makes it look easy.  The dynamics between the ponies is spot on, with Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie bringing the most laughs (and yes, I laughed while reading this issue.)  The separation of the ponies allows each group to discuss their current situation while at the same time reflect on what’s happened already.  Cook does a good job of keeping these moments entertaining as well as fleshing out the characters in the quiet, and not so quiet moments.

Cook knocks it out of the park, however, with the interaction between Chrysalis and the Cutie Mark Crusaders.  Applebloom, Sweetie Bell, and Scootaloo get more screen time here than in previous issues, and it’s just funny to see them bounce off the charismatic Queen Chrysalis.  The trio’s random thoughts about past adventures combined with their heartfelt defense of their would-be rescuers helps round them out nicely.  Chrysalis once again steals the show with her indelible charm and venomous remarks towards Twilight and her friends, and makes her one of the most entertaining, and likable, villains I can recall from a comic.

Once again, Andy Price and company bring great artwork to every panel on the page.  His expressions really let’s us know what characters are thinking or how they’re feeling without any dialogue necessary.  Seeing some of the reactions is part of the fun as you really have to look at the characters to make sense of some scenes, like when one of the Crusaders tells a bad joke while the other Crusaders look at her, almost disgusted.  Not only that, the amount of visual variety and colorful environments really give a pleasant atmosphere to the issue.  While this issue is full of happy and funny moments, there are some really dark and eerie moments to go along with them.  There’s one panel of an angry and carnivorous Queen Chrysalis that looks so cool, and is unlike any other image of her in the entire issue, it just has to be seen to be believed.

Once again, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic is a comic book series well worth the time of any fan of the animated series or all ages comic book adventures.  It really is a great book, and one I look forward to each and every month.  I hope you check it out; if you’re in the market for some good old-fashioned fun in Equestria, you won’t be disappointed!

Review by Andrew Mathieu